Rachel Tessman always has very creative alternate projects for the monthly Paper Pumpkin kits and November was no exception. One of her alternates was to create a reindeer with elements from the kit. You can see the video HERE. I don't have the punch Rachel used but I did find some that would do the trick.
Stamps - Carols of Christmas, November 2017 Paper Pumpkin Kit
Ink - Memento Black, Garden Green and Cherry Cobbler Markers
Card Stock - Very Vanilla, Basic Black, Cherry Cobbler, Soft Suede, Colour Theory DSP, Red Glimmer, October 2017 Paper Pumpkin Kit (plaid)
Other - 1/2" circle punch, Card Front Builder Dies, Leaf punch, googly eyes, Wink of Stella, Ornament Punch (retired), Gold Twine (retired), Mini Glue Dots, Stampin' Dimensionals